Car insurance recommendations?

Hi all - coming up on a renewal for my boyfriend's car insurance and Geico is quoting us a 50% increase in my 6-month premium with no changes to our driving record (23, no tickets/accidents). I read through the thread from a month or so ago and lots of folks talked about switching between Geico and Progressive when whoever you currently have came up with one of these crazy increases. I did this successfully last year but now they are both quoting the same ~50% increase. I also checked State Farm, Allstate and Amica and all of these were worse. I don't want to decrease my level of coverage. Any recommendations of local companies or other alternatives that might do better? Thanks!

Edit: Just want to add a list of the companies that I now know for sure are the same or more than Geico/Progressive, based on current pricing.

#car

#lemon8car

#caressentials

#caraccessories

#AskLemon8